I recently made a trip to Massachusetts, where I would be, as I told people, "visiting relatives, living and dead." And along the way, I knew I'd be able to get some pictures of heraldry, too. Because we'd been to Massachusetts before: once in 2008, and again in 2022. On the 2008 trip, we stayed in the Boston area, and I took a lot of photos of the heraldry we saw, but I was using my old 35mm film camera, and took fewer duplicate photos to save film, and couldn't see how the pictures turned out until I got home and had the film developed. As it turned out, a lot of them were either too dark, slightly out of focus, or both.
In 2022, I had a high-quality digital SLR camera that would let me take multiple pictures of each item, so that I would be sure that more of them would come out properly, but we didn't stay in Boston; instead we were down by Cape Cod the whole time, so I wasn't able to get back to the burying grounds in Boston.
I sought to rectify that on this trip, and over the next several posts we're going to review the armorial headstones, tombstones, and memorials found in Copp's Hill Burying Ground, Granary Burying Ground, and King's Chapel Burying Ground, as well as in the interior of King's Chapel. (On this last, I did ask before hauling out my camera. They permit photographs, but not flash, in the interior of the building. "Lucky" for me, I purchased my digital SLR with the ability to take good pictures in low-light situations in mind. I put "lucky" in quotes, because luck had nothing to do with it!)
My first stop was at Copp's Hill Burying Ground, where the first item of business was personal: to find the headstone of my step-8th-great-grandmother, Judith (Itchenor) Copp. (Yes, she was married to my 8th-great-grandfather, William Copp, who owned the land and gave his name to "Copp's Hill." He died in 1670 and was buried here, but has no marker.) But here is his second wife's stone!
Alas, this is probably not the actual place of her burial; in the late 1800s it was decided to rearrange all of the headstones in the burying ground into nice, neat rows, but without regard to the actual burial sites of the individuals so memorialized. Nonetheless, it's her headstone, and I was able to stop by and introduce myself to her.
Having done that, I was able to wander about the rest of the burying ground finding and photographing armorial tombstones. Today, we're going to look at the first two of these, the tombstones of John Clark (died 1728) and his brother, William (died 1743). The brothers are buried next to each other along one wall of the burying ground.
Having done that, I was able to wander about the rest of the burying ground finding and photographing armorial tombstones. Today, we're going to look at the first two of these, the tombstones of John Clark (died 1728) and his brother, William (died 1743). The brothers are buried next to each other along one wall of the burying ground.
Reliquæ
JOHANNIS CLARKE, Armig:
laudasissime Senatoris et Medicinæ Doctoris;
Probitate Modestia
et Mansuetudine præclaari
Terram reliquit Decem 5, 1728, ætat. 62
Nomen et Pietas manent post Funera.
Here luyes the mortal part of
WILLIAM CLARK Esqr
An Eminent Merchant of this Town, and
An Honorable Counsellor for
the Province:
Who Distinguished Himself as a Faithful and Affectionate
Friend, a Fair and generous Trader,
Loyal To His Prince,
Yet always Zealous for the Freedom of his
Countrey. A Despiser of
Sorry Persons
and little Actions, An Enemy to Priestcraft and
Enthusiasm, Ready to relieve and help the Wretched.
A Lober of good Men
of Various Denominations, and a
Reverent Worshipper
Of the Deity.
The Copp’s Hill Burying Ground Guide, p 18, tells us: “Wm. Clark, the wealthiest of Boston’s ship owners. During the French & Indian War (1744-1749), he lost 40 ships and that hastened his death shortly afterward. Adjoining it is the tomb of his brother, Dr. John Clark, physician and its inscription is in Latin. Seven succeeding generations all produced doctors with the same name. This tomb is called ‘the Winslow Tomb,’ because Samuel Winslow, sexton of 1st Baptist Church, took it over and carved his name as rightful owner.”
These arms are found in the Gore Roll of Arms, an 18th Century roll of arms made in colonial Boston, in the second and third quarters of the inescutcheon of pretense on the arms of McAdams. They are blazoned: Argent a ragged staff bendwise between three roundels sable. The crest on the tombstones is: A goose crowned, gorged and chained maintaining in its dexter foot a roundel.
In his review of the arms found in the then-newly-rediscovered Gore Roll, Harold Bowditch, in "The Gore Roll of Arms," Collections 29 (1-4) of the Rhode Island Historical Society,* noted: "The coat here given for Clarke and previously used on the stones at Copp's Hill has not been found under this name in Edmondson or Burke; it appears to be a variant of a well known Clark coat: Silver a bend gules between three roundles sable on the bend three swans silver. So far as I know no valid claim to this coat exists on the part of any American Clark family. Papworth['s Ordinary of British Armorials] gives a bend raguly between three or six roundles for Walworth, a bend embattled between six roundles for Burnell, and a ragged staff in bend between seven roundles for Sayre."
In looking elsewhere for other possible sources for this coat of arms, I found the Dictionary of British Arms gives us Clerk/Clerke/Clark and cites several individuals bearing "On a bend between three roundels three birds" and "Argent on a bend gules between three roundels sable three swans or."
So, interesting armorial tombstones, but are they also additional evidence that even 300 years ago, in 18th Century Boston, Massachusetts, people were being sold their "family crest" by what we now call "bucket shop heralds"?
* This is where I first saw Dr. Bowditch's review of the arms in the Gore Roll. His review of all of these arms can also be found in a 2006 book, The Gore Roll, written and published by myself (http://www.appletonstudios.com/BooksandGames.htm), and more recently in 2024 in a facsimile edition, The Gore Roll: The Earliest Known Roll of Arms in America, published by the New England Historic Genealogical Society (https://shop.americanancestors.org/collections/heraldry/products/the-gore-roll?pass-through=true).


